Welded Pipe Manufacturing Methods: ERW, LSAW, SSAW and Seamless Compared
Mar 06, 2024
Four Production Routes for Steel Pipe
A steel pipe is made in one of two fundamentally different ways. It is either rolled from a solid billet so that no weld seam exists, or it is formed from coil or plate and the seam is welded shut. The welded family splits again by seam direction and by welding process, giving four commercial routes that cover almost every diameter used in industry. Choosing between them is a question of diameter, wall thickness, pressure class, length tolerance and cost per metre.
| Route | Seam type | Typical outside diameter | Usual service |
|---|---|---|---|
| ERW / HFW | Single longitudinal, forged | 21 - 660 mm | Low and medium pressure water, gas, structural and mechanical duty |
| LSAW | Single longitudinal, welded inside and outside | 406 - 1422 mm | High-pressure oil and gas transmission lines |
| SSAW / HSAW | Helical, welded inside and outside | 219 - 3500 mm | Large-diameter water lines, piling, low and medium pressure duty |
| Seamless | None | Small to medium, hot rolled or cold drawn | High-pressure and high-temperature process service |
ERW and HFW Pipe
Electric resistance welding and high-frequency welding form coil into a tube and heat the abutting edges with a high-frequency current until the metal reaches forging temperature, then squeeze the edges together without filler metal. Because no filler is added and no flux is used, the seam is metallurgically close to the parent strip, the process runs continuously at high speed, and the cost per metre is the lowest of the four routes. The limit is wall thickness: above roughly 12 mm to 16 mm the current cannot heat the full wall evenly, so the process gives way to arc welding. Weld-line toughness can also be reduced by the rapid thermal cycle, which is why line pipe specifications for critical duty place limits on the seam.
LSAW Pipe
Longitudinal submerged arc welding starts from plate. The plate is crimped and formed into a cylinder by the UOE press sequence or by the JCOE sequence, and the longitudinal seam is then welded inside and outside under a blanket of flux. Two or more passes are normal on heavy wall, and the inside and outside beads are produced separately so that penetration is complete. The route is the standard answer for large-diameter line pipe because it delivers high dimensional accuracy, a compact plant footprint relative to diameter, and a seam that can be radiographed along its whole length. Wall thickness beyond 25 mm is routine.
SSAW or HSAW Pipe
Spiral, or helical, submerged arc welding winds coil at an adjustable spiral angle and welds the helical seam on both sides. The same coil width can therefore produce a wide range of finished diameters simply by changing the angle, which makes the route economical for very large diameters, including piling pipe and large water mains. The helical seam is longer than an equivalent longitudinal seam, so the weld is distributed around the circumference rather than concentrated on one line, and radiographic inspection covers the full seam when the specification requires it.
The weld seam is the quality focus of welded pipe, which is why API 5L and the other line pipe and pressure pipe standards require hydrostatic testing together with eddy-current or ultrasonic inspection of the seam, and radiographic inspection of the seam for LSAW and SSAW product. A correctly made welded seam is not automatically weaker than seamless pipe. The grade, the welding procedure, the amount of weld metal and the inspection scope determine whether the pipe is fit for the intended service. Where the risk of a seam defect cannot be tolerated, seamless pipe remains the reference option for high-pressure and high-temperature service.
Choosing a Welding Process
The pipe-making route is fixed by the mill, but the joining process used on site is a separate decision. The practical rules below cover carbon steel and stainless steel piping work.
Field and repair welding - shielded metal arc welding for versatility and portability, with tungsten inert gas welding for stainless and alloy root passes.
Production welding of thin to medium sections - metal inert gas or metal active gas welding for carbon steel, and tungsten inert gas or laser welding for stainless steel.
Thick sections, long seams, high deposition - submerged arc welding, whether the seam is straight or helical.
High-volume small and medium pipe - high-frequency welding on the ERW line.
Dissimilar metals and precision components - explosion welding, diffusion welding, friction welding or brazing.
Process selection also depends on position: vertical and overhead joints are normally made with a consumable electrode process, while flat shop joints can use the higher deposition rates of submerged arc welding. Preheating, interpass temperature control and post-weld treatment follow the qualified welding procedure specification for the grade and wall thickness involved.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is seamless pipe always better than welded pipe?
No. Seamless pipe has no weld seam to inspect, which suits high-pressure and high-temperature service, but welded pipe is made to tight dimensional tolerance, is available in much larger diameters, and is inspected along the seam by eddy current, ultrasonic or radiographic methods. Fitness for service depends on grade, wall thickness and inspection scope.
Q: What diameter range does ERW pipe cover?
Electric resistance and high-frequency welded pipe is normally produced from about 21 mm to 660 mm outside diameter, with wall thickness generally below 12 mm to 16 mm because the high-frequency current must heat the full wall evenly.
Q: Why is LSAW pipe used for transmission lines?
The UOE and JCOE forming routes give accurate roundness and straightness on large diameters, and the longitudinal seam welded inside and outside under flux can be radiographed over its full length. That combination meets the toughness and defect-tolerance requirements of high-pressure gas and oil transmission.
Q: How is the spiral seam of SSAW pipe inspected?
The helical seam is welded on both sides and inspected by ultrasonic or radiographic methods along its full length, with a hydrostatic test applied to the finished pipe. Spiral seams are longer than longitudinal seams, so inspection coverage is specified explicitly on the order.
Q: Which welding process should be used for stainless steel piping?
Tungsten inert gas welding is used for root passes and for thin wall stainless work because it gives clean, controlled penetration, while metal inert gas welding with the matching filler is used for fill and cap passes. The weld and the heat-affected zone are usually cleaned of heat tint afterwards to preserve corrosion resistance.
Q: What does API 5L require for a welded seam?
API 5L requires hydrostatic testing of the finished pipe together with non-destructive inspection of the weld seam, including radiographic inspection for longitudinal and spiral submerged arc welded product. The inspection extent and acceptance limits are stated in the specification level called up on the order.







