A333 vs A106 Pipe: Low-Temperature and High-Temperature Carbon Steel Compared
Sep 21, 2023
A333 vs A106: The Short Answer
ASTM A333 is the low-temperature pipe specification; ASTM A106 is the high-temperature pipe specification. A333 pipe is impact tested at a specified sub-zero temperature so that it will not turn brittle in cold service, while A106 pipe is a general-purpose seamless carbon steel pipe for hot service and carries no low-temperature toughness requirement. The two standards sit at opposite ends of the temperature scale, and for that reason they are not interchangeable.
| Item | ASTM A333 | ASTM A106 |
|---|---|---|
| Full title | Seamless and Welded Steel Pipe for Low-Temperature Service | Seamless Carbon Steel Pipe for High-Temperature Service |
| Design intent | Low-temperature service down to −45 °C and below | High-temperature service, roughly up to 425 °C |
| Grades | 1, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11 | A, B, C |
| Most common grade | Grade 6 | Grade B |
| Product form | Seamless or welded | Seamless only |
| Charpy impact test | Mandatory at a specified low temperature | Not required; available only as supplementary requirement S5 |
| Heat treatment | Normalised, or quenched and tempered | Hot-finished with no heat treatment required; cold-drawn tube must be heat treated |
| Typical uses | LNG, cold-climate pipelines, refrigeration, propane and ammonia lines | Boilers, steam lines, heaters, refinery and power-plant piping |
What Is A333 Pipe? Grades and Impact Temperatures
ASTM A333, also published as ASME SA333, is the standard specification for seamless and welded steel pipe for low-temperature service and other applications with required notch toughness. It exists for one reason: ordinary carbon steel loses ductility as temperature falls and can fracture without visible warning, which engineers call brittle fracture. A333 closes that gap by requiring every heat to pass a Charpy V-notch impact test at a specified low temperature.
The standard covers nine grades, and Grade 6 is by far the most widely ordered. The table below shows what separates them.
| Grade | Alloy type | Minimum impact test temperature | Typical application |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gr. 1 | Carbon-manganese | −45 °C | Propane, ammonia and refrigerated gas lines |
| Gr. 3 | 3.5% nickel | −100 °C | Petrochemical and cryogenic process piping |
| Gr. 4 | Nickel-chromium-copper | −100 °C | Duty similar to Grade 3 |
| Gr. 6 | Carbon-manganese | −45 °C | The workhorse grade for LNG receiving and cold-climate pipelines |
| Gr. 7 | 2.25% nickel | −75 °C | Oil and gas lines in cold regions |
| Gr. 8 | 9% nickel | −195 °C | LNG storage and transfer at −162 °C |
| Gr. 9 | Nickel-copper | −75 °C | Cryogenic equipment and exchangers |
| Gr. 10 | Manganese-molybdenum | −60 °C | Low-temperature heat-exchanger piping |
| Gr. 11 | 36% nickel | Per project specification | LNG service needing low thermal expansion |
For most procurement, A333 Grade 6 is the default answer. It is a carbon-manganese steel that passes the −45 °C impact test, which covers the large majority of low-temperature piping projects. Only when the design temperature drops below −45 °C do buyers step up to a nickel-bearing grade such as Grade 3 or Grade 8.
What Is A106 Pipe?
ASTM A106, also published as ASME SA106, is the standard specification for seamless carbon steel pipe for high-temperature service. It is the default carbon steel pipe for boilers, steam lines, heat exchangers and refinery piping where the fluid runs hot. The standard covers three grades, A, B and C, and Grade B accounts for the bulk of demand. In practice A106 Grade B is used up to about 425 °C; beyond that, engineers move to alloy steels such as A335 P11 or A335 P22.
Two facts about A106 drive most specification decisions. First, it is seamless only: there is no welded version in the standard. Second, it has no low-temperature impact test requirement. The material may perform acceptably at −20 °C in many cases, but that performance cannot be claimed on a specification basis, so the material cannot be certified for low-temperature service.
The Differences That Actually Matter
1. Temperature range. A106 Grade B is designed for hot service, from roughly −29 °C up to about 425 °C. A333 Grade 6 is qualified down to −45 °C by impact testing. When a line can see −30 °C or colder, as in cold climates, winter start-up, or letdown and blowdown systems where expanding gas chills the pipe, most design codes such as ASME B31.3 require impact-tested material, and that usually means A333.
2. The impact test is the defining difference. A333 Grade 6 requires a Charpy V-notch impact test at −45 °C with a minimum average absorbed energy of 18 J, with no individual specimen below 14 J. A106 Grade B has no such requirement; an impact test can be ordered as supplementary requirement S5, but it is not part of the standard. That is exactly why A106 should not be substituted for A333 in cold service.
3. Seamless-only versus seamless or welded. A106 is seamless only. A333 may be supplied seamless or welded. Where filler metal is added during welding, the product falls under ASTM A671 instead; a filler-free weld keeps it within A333. Either way, low-temperature welded pipe needs the weld and heat-affected zone heat treated to restore toughness.
4. Chemistry: the carbon matches, the impurities do not. A333 Grade 6 does not have a lower carbon content than A106 Grade B. Both are capped at 0.30% carbon with the same 0.29–1.06% manganese range. What changes is impurity control: A333 Grade 6 limits phosphorus and sulfur to 0.025% each, against 0.035% each in A106 Grade B, and it requires fully killed, fine-grain steel. Phosphorus and sulfur are the elements most damaging to Charpy toughness, and killing the steel with silicon and aluminium lowers the ductile-to-brittle transition temperature. A106 does not mandate the killed, fine-grain practice. Nickel appears only in the higher A333 grades, at 3.5% in Grade 3 and 9% in Grade 8.
| Element (%) | A333 Gr. 6 | A106 Gr. B |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon, C | 0.30 max | 0.30 max |
| Manganese, Mn | 0.29 – 1.06 | 0.29 – 1.06 |
| Phosphorus, P | 0.025 max | 0.035 max |
| Sulfur, S | 0.025 max | 0.035 max |
| Silicon, Si | 0.10 min | 0.10 min |
| Chromium, Cr | 0.30 max | 0.40 max |
| Copper, Cu | 0.40 max | 0.40 max |
| Molybdenum, Mo | 0.12 max | 0.15 max |
| Nickel, Ni | 0.40 max | 0.40 max |
| Vanadium, V | 0.08 max | 0.08 max |
| Niobium, Nb | 0.02 max | – |
5. Strength does not separate them. On tensile and yield strength the two grades are essentially identical, so the strength tables will not make the selection for you.
| Property | A333 Gr. 6 | A106 Gr. B |
|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength, min | 415 MPa | 415 MPa |
| Yield strength, min | 240 MPa | 240 MPa |
| Elongation, longitudinal, min | 30% | 30% |
| Charpy impact at −45 °C | Required, 18 J average | Not required |
Choosing Between Them, and Substitution Rules
Choose A106 Grade B when the lowest design metal temperature stays above about −29 °C and the service is hot: steam, boiler feed, hot process fluids, refinery lines. It is seamless, widely stocked and lower in cost.
Choose A333 Grade 6 when the line is exposed to −45 °C or below, or when the design code requires impact-tested material: LNG plants, cold-climate installations, refrigeration, propane and ammonia storage, and any depressurisation service that can chill the pipe quickly. Below −45 °C, step up to the nickel grades such as Grade 3 or Grade 8 for true cryogenic duty.
Can A106 be substituted for A333? Not in low-temperature service. A106 Grade B may match the tensile numbers, but it carries no impact-test guarantee, so using it where the code demands notch toughness is a design non-compliance. The reverse direction is safer: A333 Grade 6 meets or exceeds A106 Grade B requirements on chemistry and strength, which is why dual-certified A333 Grade 6 and A106 Grade B pipe is a common stocking item that can be drawn for either specification. The price difference is real, however, because of the mandatory impact testing, the tighter impurity limits and the killed fine-grain practice, so there is no reason to pay for low-temperature capability on a project that does not need it.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can A333 be used in place of A106?
A333 Grade 6 meets or exceeds A106 Grade B on chemistry and strength, so substitution in that direction is generally acceptable and dual-certified pipe is common.
Q: Can A106 replace A333 in cold service?
No. A106 has no Charpy impact requirement in the standard, so it cannot be certified for the low-temperature service for which A333 is qualified.
Q: What impact energy does A333 Grade 6 require?
A minimum average of 18 J across the specified specimens, with no individual specimen below 14 J, tested at −45 °C.
Q: Is A333 Grade 6 lower in carbon than A106 Grade B?
No. Both are capped at 0.30% carbon. The real difference is tighter phosphorus and sulfur limits plus killed, fine-grain steel practice in A333.
Q: Is welded A106 pipe available?
The A106 specification covers seamless pipe only. Welded low-temperature pipe is handled under A333 or, when filler metal is used, under ASTM A671.
Q: Which A333 grade should be used below −45 °C?
Move to a nickel-bearing grade. Grade 3 covers −100 °C service and Grade 8 covers −195 °C for LNG duty.







