Boiler Tube Materials: Carbon, Alloy and Stainless Steel Grades Compared
Jul 09, 2025
Boiler tube material is never chosen by habit: the selection follows the metal temperature, the internal pressure and the chemistry of the flue gas or steam on both surfaces. Three material families cover almost all boiler and heat recovery work, and each one has a clearly defined working window that dictates where it can be used safely.
How Boiler Tube Material Is Selected
Selection starts with the design metal temperature of the component, not the steam outlet temperature. Water wall tubes, economisers, superheaters and main steam lines all operate at different temperatures within the same unit, so a single boiler normally uses several grades. The second variable is pressure, because higher pressure means thicker walls and thicker walls raise both the thermal stress and the welding effort. The third variable is the environment: sulphur bearing flue gas, chloride rich waste gas and steam oxidation each attack different materials, so corrosion resistance often decides the grade before strength does.
Components below roughly 450 C: carbon steel water walls and economisers
Components from 450 C to 580 C: chromium-molybdenum alloy superheaters and reheaters
Components at 600 C and above: 9% Cr and austenitic stainless main steam lines
Corrosive flue gas paths: sulphur dew point resistant or high chromium grades
Carbon Steel Boiler Tube Grades
| Grade | Key composition | Typical application |
|---|---|---|
| 20G | C 0.17-0.24% | Water wall and economiser tubes with metal temperature up to 450 C, low pressure steam lines and headers |
| SA-210C (25MnG) | Carbon-manganese steel | Tensile strength about 20% higher than 20G, used for medium pressure water walls and low temperature economisers where a thinner wall is needed |
Both grades weld easily, machine well and cost the least per metre, which is why they still account for the largest tonnage in any boiler. Their limitation is strength retention: above roughly 450 C, carbon steel loses design allowable stress quickly through creep, so alloy grades take over.
Chromium-Molybdenum Alloy Boiler Tube Grades
| Grade | Composition basis | Service temperature | Application |
|---|---|---|---|
| 15CrMoG | Cr 0.8-1.2%, Mo 0.4-0.6% | up to 540 C | Superheater and reheater tubes, steam headers |
| 12Cr1MoVG | Cr about 1.2%, Mo about 0.3%, V added | long term service up to 580 C | Main steam pipe and high temperature superheater of ultra high pressure boilers |
| T22 / P22 | Cr 2.25%, Mo 1% | up to about 580 C | Superheater tubes, headers, thick wall steam pipe |
| T23 | 2.25Cr steel with W, V and Nb additions | up to about 600 C | High heat flux water wall sections of supercritical boilers, where the stronger grade allows a thinner or more oxidation resistant wall |
Adding chromium and molybdenum raises the creep rupture strength and the resistance to steam oxidation at the same time. Vanadium and niobium refine the carbide structure, which is why the vanadium bearing grade 12Cr1MoVG can serve at a higher temperature than the plain chromium-molybdenum grade 15CrMoG at comparable wall thickness.
High Chromium and Stainless Steel Grades
Once metal temperature passes 600 C, low alloy steels can no longer carry the design stress economically and 9% Cr martensitic grades take over. T91 and P91 are based on 9Cr-1Mo with V and Nb additions, while T92 and P92 use 9Cr-2W with V and Nb. The creep strength at 600 C allows a design allowable stress of roughly 100 MPa, which makes the wall of a supercritical main steam line significantly thinner than a comparable low alloy design and greatly reduces the weight and thermal stress of the line. These grades require controlled preheat, low hydrogen welding and a full post-weld heat treatment because the martensitic structure must be tempered after welding.
For the most aggressive environments, austenitic stainless grades are used. TP304H and TP347H contain at least 18% Cr and 8% Ni; TP347H is stabilised with niobium, which prevents sensitisation and keeps high temperature strength, so it is the first choice for superheater tubes in waste to energy boilers where chloride corrosion is severe. At the cold end of the boiler, 09CrCuSb is a copper and antimony bearing steel developed for resistance to sulphuric acid dew point corrosion, and it is used for the low temperature economiser and air preheater where the exhaust gas temperature is in the 100-130 C band and acid condenses on the tube surface.
Matching Material to Working Parameters
| Working condition | Recommended material | Typical component |
|---|---|---|
| Metal temperature up to 450 C | 20G carbon steel | Low pressure economiser, water wall |
| Metal temperature 540-580 C | 15CrMoG or 12Cr1MoVG | Superheater and reheater tubes |
| Metal temperature 600 C and above | T92 or P92 high alloy steel | Supercritical main steam pipeline |
| High sulphur, acid dew point risk | 09CrCuSb | Low temperature economiser, air preheater |
| High chloride environment | TP347H stainless steel | Waste incinerator superheater |
Ordering specifications should state the grade, the governing standard, the delivery condition and the required tests, because the same nominal grade can be supplied in the hot finished or cold finished condition with different tolerances. Insist on the inspection certificate that lists the heat number, analysis, tensile and flattening or bend test results.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Which material is used for boiler tubes at low pressure?
Carbon steel such as 20G is the standard answer for water walls and economisers with metal temperature up to about 450 C, and SA-210C is selected when its higher tensile strength allows a thinner wall.
Q: When is an alloy boiler tube required instead of carbon steel?
As soon as the design metal temperature rises above roughly 450 C, creep strength becomes the controlling property and a chromium-molybdenum grade such as 15CrMoG or 12Cr1MoVG is required to keep the allowable stress within design limits.
Q: Why are T91 and T92 used for supercritical units?
Their 9% Cr composition gives outstanding creep strength at 600 C and above, so the wall thickness of a main steam line can be reduced substantially compared with a low alloy design, cutting weight, welding volume and thermal stress during start-up.
Q: What material handles chloride corrosion in a waste incinerator?
Austenitic stainless steel, typically TP347H, is used for superheater tubes because its chromium and nickel content plus niobium stabilisation resist chloride attack and retain strength above 650 C.
Q: What is 09CrCuSb used for?
It is a sulphuric acid dew point corrosion resistant steel used at the cold end of the boiler, in low temperature economisers and air preheaters where the metal temperature sits in the acid condensing band of about 100-130 C.
Q: Do boiler tubes need different delivery conditions?
Yes. Carbon steel is normally supplied as rolled or as drawn, alloy tubes are supplied heat treated, and 9% Cr grades must be supplied in a fully tempered martensitic condition with preheat and post-weld heat treatment controlled during erection.







